And the winner is:

[astrokender.livejournal.com]

Wow, this was harder than I thought. I've read and reread the entries and have finally come to a decision. Thanks to those who answered my challenge, they were all great reads!

The winner was chosen on how well I thought they interpreted Pirate Booty. And as much as I like the idea of booty staring, booty grabbing, and *drools* naked mud-wrestling, I have to give the win to cptn_shinigami for 'Treasure', wherein Smoker literally got a piece of the action.

Thanks again to all who participated!

Take it away, cptn_shinigami!